When Should You Repair or Replace Your Damaged Garage Door?

A damaged garage door will leave homeowners with two questions: How did this happen? And once the frustration fades, should I repair it or replace it? Knowing when to repair versus replace can save time, money, and plenty of stress.

Let’s explore the most common garage door issues and whether a repair or replacement makes the most sense.

What Garage Door Damages Can Be Repaired?

A broken garage door doesn’t instantly mean it’s going to be costly to replace. These damages can often be fixed at a fraction of the price of a new garage door. Here are a few of the most common issues that can be repaired easily and affordably.

Minor Dents and Dings

Everyday use and accidental bumps can lead to small dents or dings on your garage door. These minor issues are often purely cosmetic and don’t affect the door’s operation. Skilled technicians can use techniques like panel beating or suction to smooth out these dents, restoring the door’s appearance.

Broken Springs

Garage door springs are constantly under high tension and can wear down or break over time. Replacing these springs is a common repair that can quickly restore your door’s function. Since springs are complex and potentially dangerous to handle, it’s best to leave this job to the professionals to ensure safety and efficiency.

Worn or Damaged Rollers

Rollers help the garage door glide smoothly along its tracks. Over time, they may wear down or break, causing the door to moan and groan or not move properly. This issue can often sound worse than it is, but it can usually be fixed by replacing the rollers, a relatively straightforward and low-cost repair.

Track Misalignment

Garage door tracks guide the door as it opens and closes. If the tracks become misaligned, the door may not function properly, causing it to stick. In many cases, adjusting or repairing the tracks can solve the problem, saving you the cost of a new door.

Weatherstripping

Weatherstripping seals the bottom of your garage door, keeping out drafts, moisture, and pests. Over time, it can wear out, allowing unwanted elements to enter your garage. Replacing weatherstripping is a simple fix that improves your garage’s insulation and protects your space.

What Damages Can’t Be Repaired?

While many issues can be repaired, some damage is too severe, and a garage door replacement is the best choice. Here are situations where replacing the door is your best bet.

Extensive Structural Damage

If your garage door has large cracks, severe warping, or major dents, it may no longer be structurally sound. Repairing such extensive damage can be impractical, as it compromises the safety and functionality of the door.

Multiple Broken Panels

If several panels on your garage door are damaged, replacing individual ones can be costly and may not match the rest of the door. In these cases, you’ll get more bang for your buck by simply replacing the entire door.

Outdated or Obsolete Models

Older garage doors may lack modern safety features and energy efficiency, and it can be challenging to find replacement parts. If your door is outdated, upgrading to a new model can actually save you money in the long term.

Frequent Repairs

If your garage door is in constant need of repairs, it might be time to consider a replacement. Frequent fixes can quickly add up, and a new door may save you money in the long run while providing more dependable performance.

Severe Rust or Corrosion

Rust and corrosion can weaken the structure of your garage door, especially for steel doors exposed to moisture or coastal air. If the damage from rust is significant, replacing the door is often the best choice to prevent ongoing issues and maintain the door’s integrity.

Why Repair Your Garage Door?

If the damage is minor, repairing your garage door is the best option. Repairs are typically more affordable than replacements and can extend the life of your garage door without a major investment. Fixing specific components can restore functionality and appearance, letting you avoid the higher costs of a new door.

Why Replace Your Garage Door?

If your garage door is old, inefficient, or heavily damaged, a replacement is often the best option. A new door can offer improved energy efficiency, better security features, and a refreshed look for your home.

Making the Decision Between Repairs or Replacement

Deciding between a garage door repair and a replacement comes down to a few key factors: the extent of the damage, the age of the door, and the cost of repairs versus a new door. Consulting with a professional technician can provide valuable insights and help you make the best decision for your situation.

At Dominator Waikato, our experts are here to assess the condition of your garage door and recommend the most cost-effective solution. Reach out today for expert guidance on caring for your door.